Is Positive Reinforcement Training Good for Your Dog?

According to experts, positive reinforcement training, sometimes referred to as force-free, reward-based, or R+ training, is one of the most reliable and successful training techniques available for dogs.

The humane philosophy that underpins positive reinforcement training places a high value on developing a close relationship with your dog. Positive reinforcement instructs dogs via a reward system as an alternative to coercive methods or physical punishment: the dog receives a reward when they accomplish a desired skill or display a desired behavior. Because the incentive encourages the dog, it eventually picks up training cues and orders.

Usually, the reward is of a tiny treat that doesn't provide a significant amount of calories. A game, a toy, or some simple praise can occasionally inspire a dog. There are numerous methods for conducting the training and incentives that yield outcomes.

Read on to find out more about positive reinforcement training, including how to apply its key strategies to reward and reinforce your dog's good behavior, whether you've started training him or her using a different approach or want to start from scratch.

The Science and Proven Methods of Positive Reinforcement

The origins of positive reinforcement training can be traced back to the 1930s and 1940s Harvard research on "operant conditioning" by psychologist B.F. Skinner. Skinner investigated how positive and negative stimuli influenced the behavior of rats and pigeons in clinical situations. He created the phrase "operant conditioning" to describe the method by which an organism comes to identify a behavior with its outcomes.

It is all about initiating the behavior that can then elicit the reward in positive reinforcement training, as per Skinner's definition of "operant," which is defined as the activity that subsequently creates consequences.

It's simple to see why teaching a dog to perform for a treat or praise can be so successful—Skinner discovered that the same concepts apply to people as well!

The four methods of dog training

One component of what is commonly thought of as a four-quadrant paradigm of dog training is positive reinforcement strategies. The following are the quadrants:

- Positive reinforcement: is rewarding the dog with toys, treats, or praise for exhibiting the desired behavior. Additionally, some trainers combine this with "clicker training," which involves using a clicker training device to make a sound whenever the dog exhibits the desired behavior. A reward, toy, or other encouraging stimulus comes next. The dog eventually comes to link the sound of the "click" with a treat or other reward after hearing it when they sit or remain, for example.

- Negative reinforcement: When a behavior is attained or a desired behavior is obtained, a negative stimulus is removed. For instance, you may turn off an e-collar when your dog complies with your instructions. When the dog obeys a desirable signal or command, unfavorable stimuli are eliminated, as they learn.

- Positive punishment: Introducing a negative stimulus in order to make the dog behave less unwanted is known as positive punishment. Positive punishment, as defined by the Merck Veterinary Manual, "refers to applying something unpleasant to decrease a behavior," such giving a dog a smack on the nose or jerking on a leash. Among other unfavorable effects, Merck warns that this training component has a "high chance of failure" and may "increase the chance of fear or aggression."

- Negative punishment: According to Merck, "negative punishment refers to removing something positive to decrease a behavior." Usually, this involves not giving your dog a food, toy, or other important incentive when they don't behave as you would like them to.

Positive reinforcement is generally considered the best way to train

Positive reinforcement is combined with other training quadrants, such negative punishment, by certain trainers. However, a lot of trainers are completely abandoning traditional punishment-based training methods or unpleasant training.

In a statement from 2021, the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB) formally supported the use of reward-based training techniques for all canines. The AVSAB's 2021 policy document said, "Based on current scientific evidence, AVSAB recommends that only reward-based training methods are used for all dog training, including the treatment of behavior problems." "Aversive training methods are detrimental to the bond between humans and animals as well as animal welfare." (The AKC further states that instructors ought to "concentrate on positive reinforcement.")

The effectiveness of positive reinforcement training is explained by Camille Ward, a board-certified Applied Animal Behaviorist at All About Dogs, a behavioral prevention and treatment service for dogs in Michigan.

It makes sense. Similar to focusing on the positive aspects of people, we are noticing the positive aspects of dogs.

Positive reinforcement training techniques

Three primary methods are applied in different phases of training for positive reinforcement. These methods are:

  • Shaping aids in the dog's learning that exhibiting the behavior will result in a reward. This is how you can first encourage your dog for each tiny step they take in the direction of the desired behavior. Gradually, you gradually transition to rewarding your dog only when they accomplish the desired behavior. 
  • Luring is using food as an incentive to travel in the desired direction, Patricia B. McConnell, an applied animal behaviorist, defines luring as "showing the animal something it wants, usually food." 
  • Capturing and rewarding your dog's positive actions as they occur. For greatest effect, this is a terrific approach to take advantage of your dog's attention in the moment and his incentive for rewards, but it does require some consistency and patience.

Why Choose Positive Reinforcement Training?

Dogs who receive positive reinforcement are rewarded for their good conduct, which can make them happier and more involved. Experts, including the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior, advise positive reinforcement training for the following reason: Dogs that receive R+ training become significantly less nervous and more self-assured.

Positive reinforcement is based on the notion that it should essentially be fearless. When the dog errs, it is not chastised or put under pressure. The dog turns into a cooperative participant," Ward stated. "It involves preparing the dog for success, letting the dog make decisions, and then rewarding the right decisions."

Positive reinforcement is the best approach, according to Ward, "if you really want a dog that is happy and outgoing." "You will feel much better if someone sets you up for success in the workplace, gives you tasks that may have been a little challenging but still allowed you to shine, and then when you do, they tell you you're doing such a great job, than if you're working on really difficult tasks and you hear something negative that makes you feel bad." Which method would you prefer?

Things to Consider Prior to Beginning Positive Reinforcement Training

A dog of almost any age can begin positive reinforcement training. According to the American Kennel Club, it's acceptable to begin a training program based on positive reinforcement for puppies that have just arrived at your house as early as eight weeks. If you've started other forms of training on your dog, you don't need to worry about him being confused. R+ training will naturally entice your dog to its rewards.

Additionally, it's simple to get started because all you need is a basic bag of snacks.

Experiment with shaping, luring, and capturing—all of the positive reinforcement training approaches. To begin with, though, consider focusing on just one action, like sitting or going to bed. Give your dog a treat whenever they perform the desired behavior, or whenever they approach it in the case of shaping. Select foods that your dog will continue to be enthusiastic about (this recipe and idea are suitable for puppies). The goal is to present something genuinely alluring and captivating.

Some Advice for Beginning Positive Reinforcement

Alright, you've made up your mind that positive reinforcement training might be beneficial for you, and you can't wait to get going. So where should we start? Here, it's important to start out slowly and steadily and maintain consistency. The following are the key points to remember when doing positive reinforcement training:

  • Have fun with it! Since your dog is your partner, maintaining a happy attitude will yield the best outcomes. 
  • Stop if your dog appears agitated, dissatisfied, or bored. 
  • Set reasonable goals by keeping an eye on your dog. By the end of the week, you might want him to be sitting, but if you keep an eye on his development, a different objective might be more doable. 
  • Remain dependable! Take a little daily step toward achieving your first desired behavior. Rewarding positive conduct will become ingrained in the process over time.

Troubleshooting: Why Isn't Your Dog Cooperating?

Positive reinforcement training has many benefits, but since each dog is different, some will naturally become proficient in it sooner than others. Most of the time, the problems only call for additional time spent with the dog. Possible problems consist of: 

  • The dog is becoming sidetracked. The Animal Behavior College of Valencia, California, suggests that occasionally a treat may not be sufficiently "high value." Treats labeled as "high value" are frequently little bits of cheese or hot dogs. 
  • The dog is creating a negative association even with treats. This may require you to reward more frequently. According to the Animal action College, this could entail "rewarding your dog for every successful attempt toward the behavior." It can even entail giving your dog a treat every two to three seconds. (Extremely tiny goodies designed for training work well for this.)
  • You will probably need to go more slowly if your dog exhibits a wide variety of complex emotions or excessive worry. Give a dog a treat if she stays on her feet. 
  • Additionally, start over if you unintentionally encouraged an unwanted behavior. Start with little rewards that reinforce the desired behavior.

Conclusion

Positive reinforcement of all the methods for training a dog, is the most humane and successful. Along with being a healthy method to strengthen your relationship with your dog and encourage them to work toward what they want most—treats—it also benefits both of you and your pet!

Take it easy on both you and your dog and take a break if things get too hard. Remember that it's not necessary for you to handle everything alone. A certified, positive-reward dog trainer is someone you can always bring in to assist in your training.

Access The Training Now

We process your personal data as stated in our Privacy Policy. You may withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link at the bottom of any of our emails.

Close